|
What Happened This Summer
by Paul Yee
What Happened This Summer on Recommended list
In
What happened this summer, Yee has targeted a specific audience. All of
his vignettes are about Chinese young people. His stories all deal with
their struggles to balance the cultural ideals of our society with very
traditional Chinese values. The teenagers in these stories are dealing
with the issues of 'head tax' redress, homosexual siblings, church
values, teenage marriage with the sole purpose of sponsoring a whole
family for immigration, old family obligations, university versus art school,
astronaut or long distance parents, pressure to do well academically,
cheating, and returning to their own culture in Asia. Some of these
problems are universal, but all of Yee's stories have a cultural twist.
These
stories comprise the ultimate problem book. Each of the chapters deals
with one issue, though the same character may be present in many. In
one story Yee shifts from a male to a female character mid story, which
is quite confusing for the reader. These are short, sharp tales that
are almost like reading email. Yee is trying to show us that young
Chinese, new immigrants or Canadian born, have a difficult time.
Recommended for Secondary Schools. --Reviewed by: Gloria Reinheimer, teacher-librarian, Bear Creek Elementary School, SD#36 (Surrey)
Bookmark: the BC Teacher-Librarian Association
In What happened this summer, Yee has targeted a specific audience. All of his vignettes are about Chinese young people. His stories all deal with their struggles to balance the cultural ideals of our society with very traditional Chinese values. The teenagers in these stories are dealing with the issues of 'head tax' redress, homosexual siblings, church values, teenage marriage with the sole purpose of sponsoring a whole family for immigration, old family obligations, university versus art school, astronaut or long distance parents, pressure to do well academically, cheating, and returning to their own culture in Asia. Some of these problems are universal, but all of Yee's stories have a cultural twist.
These stories comprise the ultimate problem book. Each of the chapters deals with one issue, though the same character may be present in many. In one story Yee shifts from a male to a female character mid story, which is quite confusing for the reader. These are short, sharp tales that are almost like reading email. Yee is trying to show us that young Chinese, new immigrants or Canadian born, have a difficult time.
Recommended for Secondary Schools.
Reviewed by: Gloria Reinheimer, teacher-librarian, Bear Creek Elementary School, SD#36 (Surrey).
"This collection [of stories] is gutsy, as Yee tackles subjects such as teen pregnancy, drugs, sex and religion.
"What Happened This Summer" is a collection of short stories by accomplished writer, Paul Yee. In this collection, Yee presents a series of stories which detail the lives of Chinese Canadian teenagers who mostly live in Ontario. The characters, who each have a unique voice, describe their struggles, which encompass romantic relationships, difficulties bridging the gap between their experiences in their homeland and their Canadian lifestyle, and the conflict between what their parents want and what the young people desire. The language is clean and concise, and some of the stories read like monologues. Some of the characters appear as minor characters in other stories, which gives the feeling that each story is part of a larger macrocosm. Yee is adept at blending in the Canadian and Asian details, which helps bring the stories to life. Details about Chinese Canadian history and politics also add another dimension to these tales. This collection is
gutsy, as Yee tackles subjects such as teen pregnancy, drugs, sex and religion. For example in, "We're dating white guys", a teenaged girl writes in her diary about losing weight and dieting, while examining her feelings about her own developing relationship with a white boy, and comparing her romantic life to that of her cousin's. This is a brave collection that captures the experiences of Chinese Canadian teenagers and should resonate with many young Asian readers today.-By Alexis Kienlen, Ricepaper
Happy New Year by Deirdre Baker, Toronto Star
Paul Yee, recipient of numerous awards, including the Governor
General's Literary Award for his novel Ghost Train, focuses on
the modern-day lives and concerns of Chinese-Canadians in this,
his latest novel for young adults. So what did happen this summer?
A general response would be that each teen-age protagonist came
of age, grew up - and we, the reader, are privy to that process,
because each experience is related in the first person and so
we read what is going on in their heads as well as the unfolding
events.
Yee keeps the reader on their toes: there is no warning that
the narrator is going to change from chapter to chapter and since
we are not introduced formally, we even have to work out whether
the "I" is male or female. I was half-expecting the narrators
to return in cycles - instead, we catch odd glimpses of them as
they happen to pass through someone else's story. Indeed, each
story could stand alone as a short story, a vignette of the challenges
and concerns faced by each character: parental expectations and
pressure, school, homosexuality, racial stereotypes, sex, death
- in other words the full gamut of the issues considered relevant
by the majority of teenagers today. Yee's focus on the Chinese-Canadian
experience adds an extra facet to these subjects.
So, again, what happened this summer? While each person's story
could stand alone, Yee is actually setting up the strings of his
narrative to be pulled together in the final chapter. This watershed
time in all their lives reaches its peak at that point and it
is as powerful as it is unexpected. However, life does go on and,
as is so often the case, it will only be with hindsight that each
narrator will come to realise the significance of that period
in their lives: something beyond the book's telling that is up
to readers to interpret for themselves.
A thought-provoking book that will appeal to young adults who
are themselves on the brink of making life-affecting decisions
about their own futures --By Marjorie Coughlan, July 2007, PaperTigers
Gr 9 Up These intriguing, loosely linked short stories explore
the lives of Chinese-Canadian teenagers as they navigate two worlds,
struggling to meet their immigrant parents' expectations and to
also live their own lives. They must resist the usual adolescent
temptations, or embrace them, with the extra complication of never
completely fitting in. One boy works to improve his English while
deciding whether to stay in Canada with his father or return to
China with his mother. A girl wants to study photography, but
her father pressures her to secure a more lucrative career. A
boy tries to find a church that will accept his brother, who is
gay. A girl sneaks off to have sex with a classmate, though she
knows that her strict aunt will be furious if she finds out. Though
all of the stories are solidly written, none stand out as the
most accomplished, and a few are slightly melodramatic in flavor.
Characters sometimes reappear in other parts of the book as their
classmates talk or think about their situations, but each of the
nine selections also stands alone. While the adults are frequently
inflexible and pushy, the young people often come to see that
they are also proud, loving, and confused by the rules of their
new society. Teens with an interest in the immigrant experience
will likely find these stories satisfying. Miranda Doyle,
San Francisco Public Library, School Library Journal
In nine short stories, Chinese Canadian teen characters--boys,
girls, Canadian-born, newly immigrated--provide an elegantly diversified
sense of what coming of age can mean to those who are bicultural.
Yee does a compelling job of speaking as a young girl concerned
about her gay brother's acceptance in the church community; a
brash young man who finds himself with a wife and infant son;
another girl who, when dating a white boy, becomes disillusioned
by his interest in Asian cultures; and other youth. The adults
in these stories range from the fatuous to those who hold not
only readers' sympathies but those of their own teenaged children.
Most of the stories are set in Toronto, but the China from which
their families have come includes both Hong Kong and the mainland.
In one tale, two teens are amazed to find that the tunnels they've
heard of being beneath downtown Toronto aren't nuclear war bunkers
but familiar-looking shopping malls. In another, a mysterious
girl seems to appear among groups of friends as a foretelling
of fatal car accidents each clique then suffers. These stories
are accessible and engaging across ethnic and cultural lines.
Yee's teens are not only credible; they will stick with readers
just as Salinger's Glass family has.- Francisca Goldsmith,
Libn., Berkeley PL, Berkeley, CA
S--Recommend for senior high school students.
A--Recommend for advanced students and adults. This code will
help librarians and teachers working in high schools where there
are honors and advanced placement students. This also will help
KLIATT's usefulness in public libraries.
This collection features an assortment of Chinese Canadian teens
facing many common challenges while grapping with their own individual
struggles. Most of these youth are immigrants to Canada and vary
widely in terms of how successfully they have adapted to their
new homes and life situations. One grudgingly leaves Hong Kong
to come to Toronto, where he is soon married with a young son,
an arrangement that enables his father to repay a long-standing
debt. Another seeks a church community that will accept and support
her gay brother. The young woman in Astronaut Dads Are a Pain tries to convince her father to go to art college while in Reading This Novel Made Me Have Sex, Julie chafes under
her aunt's harsh rules. These stories highlight the difficulties
that confront many contemporary Chinese Canadian teens who must
balance the realities of their lives in western society with their
parents' high expectations and often conflicting goals and ideals.
Yee is well-known for his ability to capture the experience of
Chinese immigrants in Canada. This excellent book is for teen
readers who are interested in a realistic treatment of this topic.
The snapshots that he provides of Chinese youth illustrate both
the typical teen crises in their lives along with the added challenges
of families adjusting to a new culture. The short-story format
might not make it fly off the shelf, but the collection is nonetheless
a good recommendation in a classroom or public library setting. - Lisa Doucet, VOYA
Toronto
Star Reciew by Deirdre Baker
From School Library Journal
Grade 9 Up These intriguing, loosely linked short stories explore
the lives of Chinese-Canadian teenagers as they navigate two worlds,
struggling to meet their immigrant parents' expectations and to
also live their own lives. They must resist the usual adolescent
temptations, or embrace them, with the extra complication of never
completely fitting in. One boy works to improve his English while
deciding whether to stay in Canada with his father or return to
China with his mother. A girl wants to study photography, but
her father pressures her to secure a more lucrative career. A
boy tries to find a church that will accept his brother, who is
gay. A girl sneaks off to have sex with a classmate, though she
knows that her strict aunt will be furious if she finds out. Though
all of the stories are solidly written, none stand out as the
most accomplished, and a few are slightly melodramatic in flavor.
Characters sometimes reappear in other parts of the book as their
classmates talk or think about their situations, but each of the
nine selections also stands alone. While the adults are frequently
inflexible and pushy, the young people often come to see that
they are also proud, loving, and confused by the rules of their
new society. Teens with an interest in the immigrant experience
will likely find these stories satisfying.Miranda Doyle, San
Francisco Public Library Copyright Reed Business Information,
a division of Reed Elsevier Inc.
In a series of short stories, Yee looks at the variety of experiences
of nine Chinese-Canadian teens. Each of them has mixed if not
wholly negative feelings about their lives as immigrants; for
the most part, they understand their parents' desire for them
to have a better life and education and in particular to be free
from Communism, but that desire for their children's freedom and
success does not extend to their actual home lives. There, the
parents rule with iron wills, and the teens chafe under expectations
as relatively benign as wanting them to wear modest clothing and
get good grades, to forcing them to marry against their wishes
in order to repay a family debt. The stories are individually
compelling, but they are similar in their melancholy tone, with
the young people's victories over this sort of oppression being
small to nonexistent; many simple end up resentful and stuck.
Yee never signals that what initially appear to be chapters are
really separate stories that are only loosely connected through
passing references to characters from other stories--the narrators
seem to know of one another, but the stories don't particularly
overlap--leaving the reader expecting a continuous narration thrown
for a loop. Nonetheless, the collection is poignant, and it points
to a serious problem of isolation and discontent in Chinese-Canadian
teen culture, sadly offering no remedy other than the act of storytelling
itself. KC. The Bulletin for the Center for Children's Books
CM,
Volume XIII Number 8, December 8, 2006
This collection of nine short stories addresses the experience
of today's immigrant Chinese youth coming of age in Canada. A
modern hip-hopper reluctantly agrees to an arranged marriage to
honor a promise his grandfather made in "You Cannot Mess with
Fate." In "Reading This Novel Made Me Have Sex," arguably the
strongest offering, a girl compares her restricted life to that
of the protagonist in Margaret Atwood's Handmaid's Tale, as she
faces a pregnancy scare and defies her domineering aunt. Other
tales also focus on young people torn between their parents' traditional
expectations and the siren song of pop culture. The very specific
Canadian setting, the monotony of the first-person voices, and
the occasionally clunky insertion of Chinese historical and political
fact are likely to limit readership for this. However, as a thoughtful
examination of a little-known cultural clash, the collection may
find a place in larger libraries, libraries serving large Asian
populations, or where Yee's Dead Man's Gold and Other Stories
(2002) has an audience. --Jennifer Hubert Copyright American
Library Association.
In this collection of linked short stories, Paul Yee delivers
a gritty, often bleak view of the lives of ethnic Chinese teens
living in Canada, mainly in the suburbs of Toronto and Vancouver.
These teens, products of the diaspora of mainland China and Hong
Kong after the handover of the British colony, attempt in a variety
of ways to bridge two worlds. Not a few of them find the process
of transplantation a painful, alienating and often humiliating
experience.
Absentee parents who still live in China or Hong Kong and fly
in for periodic visits ("astronaut dads"), ferocious expectations
and difficulty learning English are part of the climate that envelops
these kids.
The titles of these stories -- Astronaut Dads are a Pain, I Thought
Life was Getting Better, Don't Trust Your Parents -- more than
hint at their tenor. Yee's use of the "I," or first-person narrator,
guarantees a compelling and edgy immediacy to each of them. In
the story Never Go to School with a Hangover, Wen, a high school
student, has a hangover, a bad one. "No more drinking on school
nights, I warn myself. Not after last night. My head hurts. The
eyes blur. The stomach lurches."
On this particular morning, Lisa Yip, a human rights activist,
is visiting Wen's class, attempting to fan the students' outrage
at the injustices, including the head tax, perpetrated against
early Chinese immigrants. Wen is in a contrary mood; he refutes
all her assumptions and consummates his attack by vomiting on
her feet when she deposits a pile of petitions for redress on
his desk.
Later that same day, tooling along on the 401 in his car, Wen
thinks about what has gone on in the class. In an internal monologue,
he notes that the teachers at his school "want us to feel like
we belong. But then they keep bringing in Lisa Yips, who remind
us that we're different." Furthermore, Wen thinks, it is not up
to him and his friends to "fight the racism of the past." --Susan
Perren, Globe and Mail November 4th 2006
For Chinese teens who have grown up with traditional family values
and expectations, fitting into contemporary Canadian society can
be difficult. In this collection of loosely connected short stories
set in Toronto,Governor General's Award recipient Yee explores
the many emotional struggles and challenges Chinese immigrant
teens face.
Astronaut Dads Are a Pain centres on Julia, an aspiring photographer
who lives with her mother in Canada. When her father, who lives
in Taipei, makes one of his monthly visits, he belittles Julia
for her interest,telling her he expects her to pursue a more traditional
career. "My father lives one continent and one ocean away," she
says, "yet runs my life as if he owns the world's most powerful
remote control."
In I Thought Life Was Getting Better, Ha-lan discovers his brother
is gay. Knowing that he will be abandoned by the family once his
secret is out, Han-lan sets out in search of a church that will
accept him for who he is. And in You Can't Mess With Fate, an
18-year-old boy finds he is suddenly a husband and father in a
country where he doesn't speak the language, a position forced
on him in order to pay his father's debt.
Despite the seriousness of the issues, Yee's upbeat style and
amusing twists on the clashes of cultures make every story a pleasure
to read. The only drawback is that they are told in first person,
which causes some confusion. In this case, third person might
have been a better choice. But it is a small criticism, considering
the power of the writing and the appeal of the stories. With their
inclusion of angst over topics many Canadian-born youth would
never think twice about, the stories will speak to immigrants
of all ethnic backgrounds. -- Montreal Gazette and Edmonton
Journal
Exceptional stories grasp lives of Chinese-Canadian teens
PAUL Yee was born in Saskatchewan but moved to Vancouver at the
tender age of two.
Since becoming involved in volunteer community work as a teenager,
he has become an important voice in telling not only the history
of the Chinese community in Canada but also in exploring the feelings
of its people.
His novel Ghost Train won the Governor General's Literary Award
in 1996. Yee's new book of short stories, "What Happened This
Summer", is exceptional in its grasp of the lives and emotions
of the young people whose parents have emigrated from Hong Kong,
Beijing and Taiwan.
The stories illustrate poignantly how these teenagers are caught
between the hopes and demands of their parents and the strictures
of their culture and the freedom and aspirations that they feel
entitled to in Canada.
The stories explore issues such as "astronaut dads," who live
in Hong Kong or Taiwan and visit only briefly a couple of times
a year; girls dating "white guys" and trying to keep it a secret
from their parents; or children wanting to return to China against
parents' wishes to "study English and make a better life in Canada."
*Yee*'s characters are achingly realistic, and the situations
show his understanding of how difficult it is for many of these
young people to bridge the gap between their background and present
circumstances.
Hopefully, Yee's book will contribute to a greater understanding
of their dilemma. --by Helen Norrie, Winnipeg Free Press Sunday,
August 20, 2006
|